In ‘History of Piracy in the Caribbean’, readers are treated to an enthralling exploration of buccaneers, privateers, and the maritime rogues who wove the rich, tumultuous fabric of Caribbean history. The anthology captures a vivid array of literary styles, from Daniel Defoe’s meticulously researched accounts to the romanticized narratives of Captain Charles Johnson, and the anecdotal collections of Charles Ellms. Each piece, while distinct, contributes to a comprehensive portrayal of piratical life, highlighting the diversity and depth of pirate folklore without overshadowing factual authenticity. Standout pieces include harrowing tales of survival and treachery on the high seas, often blurring the lines between villain and hero, reality and myth. The editors and contributors, each rooted deeply in their era’s literary and historical context, create a mosaic from the 17th and 18th centuries’ perspectives, reflecting the shifts and continuities within piracy’s enduring legacy. These authors, celebrated for their early works on piracy—whether as contemporary analyses or later reflections—all contribute to a richer, multi-dimensional understanding of pirate lore in line with broader historical and cultural narratives of the colonial Caribbean. ‘History of Piracy in the Caribbean’ is a must-read for both enthusiasts of maritime history and general readers alike. Its pages promise not only engaging narratives but also invaluable insights into the notorious and charismatic figures who once roamed the Caribbean waters. By exploring this collection, one gains a profound appreciation of both the historical impact and the literary representation of Caribbean piracy, bridging academic inquiry with captivating storytelling.