According to the US Constitution, if a bill is not returned to Congress by the president within ten days of receiving it and Congress has adjourned, the bill is effectively vetoed. The so-called pocket veto dates at least as far back as the presidency of James Madison (1808-1816), but the constitutionality of its use had not been considered by the Supreme Court until
Okanogan et al. v. United States was decided in 1929, during the last year of Chief Justice Taft’s tenure. Despite responding to a situation in American Indian law, the Pocket Veto Case is notable for the fact that its final decision had nothing whatsoever to do with Indian law. The Okanogan Tribe is barely mentioned at all in the Court’s unanimous opinion, delivered by Justice Edward Sanford, which ultimately concluded that the pocket veto is a constitutional exercise of presidential authority.
The Unusual Story of the Pocket Veto Case explores the underlying tension between congressional authority and the executive prerogative. Especially today, with such tension very much in evidence, it becomes all the more important to understand how and why the Constitution actually appears to encourage it. Studying
Okanogan et al. v. United States and use of the pocket veto provides an excellent example of the tension between Congress and the president.
Cuprins
Editor’s Preface
Preface
Part I. The History of a New Federal Tribunal
1. the Long Road to the Court of Claims
2. Approaching the Gates of the Court: The Six Tribes and Congress until 1927
3. Still Waiting at the Gates of the Court, 1926-1928
Part II. The Pocket Veto: Challengers and Challenges
4. Reacting to the Pocket Veto, 1927-1928
5. The Supreme Court Agrees to Read and Listen, 1928-1929
6. The Pocket Veto and the Supreme Court, 1929-1938
Part III. Beyond the Pocket Veto Case
7. Digging Deeper into the Pocket Veto Cases, 1970-1987
Conclusion
Chronology
Bibliographic Essay
Index
Despre autor
Jonathan Lurie is professor of history emeritus, Rutgers University-Newark Campus, and author of numerous books, including The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment and Military Justice in America, both from Kansas.