Essays considering how global fundamentalism influences our understanding of modern Christianity, Judaism, and Islam
Thirty years after the Iranian Revolution and more than a decade since the events of 2001, the time is right to examine what the discourse on fundamentalism has achieved and where it might head from here. In this volume editors Simon A. Wood and David Harrington Watt offer eleven interdisciplinary perspectives framed by the debate between advocates and critics of the concept of fundamentalism that investigate it with regard to Christianity, Islam, and Judaism. The essays are integrated through engagement with a common selection of texts on fundamentalism and a common set of questions about the utility and disadvantages of the term, its varied application by scholars of particular groups, and the extent to which the term can encompass a cross-cultural set of religious responses to modernity.
Although the notion of fundamentalism as a global phenomenon dates from around 1980, the term itself originated in North American Protestantism approximately six decades earlier and acquired pejorative connotations within five years of its invention. Since the early 1990s, however, many scholars have endorsed the view that the notion of fundamentalism—as relying on literalist interpretations of the scriptures, firm commitment to patriarchy, or refusal to confine religious matters to the private sphere—facilitates our understanding of modern religion by enabling us to identify and label structurally analogous developments in different religions. Critics of the term have identified problems with it, above all that the idea of global fundamentalism confuses more than it clarifies and unjustifiably overlooks, downplays, or homogenizes difference more than it identifies a genuine homogeny.
The editor’s rigorous exploration of both the usefulness and the limitations of the concept make it an excellent counterpoint to the many books that have a great deal to say about the former and very little to say about the latter. It will also serve as an ideal text for religious studies, history, and anthropology courses that explore the complex interface between religion and modernity as well as courses on theory and method in religious studies.
İçerik tablosu
Contents
Series Editor’s Preface viii
Acknowledgments ix
Introduction 1
Simon A. Wood and David Harrington Watt
Fundamentalists of the 1920s and 1930s 18
David Harrington Watt
The Idea of Militancy in American Fundamentalism 36
Dan D. Crawford
Fundamentalism and Christianity 55
Margaret Bendroth
‘America Is No Different, ‘ ‘America Is Different’—Is There an
American Jewish Fundamentalism? Part I. American Habad 70
Shaul Magid
‘America Is No Different, ‘ ‘America Is Different’—Is There an
American Jewish Fundamentalism? Part II. American Satmar 92
Shaul Magid
The Jewish Settler Movement and the Concept of Fundamentalism 108
Jean Axelrad Cahan
The Concept of Global Fundamentalism: A Short Critique 125
Simon A. Wood
Muslim ‘Fundamentalism, ‘ Salafism, Sufism, and Other Trends 144
Khalid Yahya Blankinship
Fundamentalism and Shiism 163
Lynda Clarke
Fundamentalism, Khomeinism, and the Islamic Republic of Iran 181
Lynda Clarke
Fundamentalism Diluted: From Enclave to Globalism in
Conservative Muslim Ecological Discourse 199
David L. Johnston
Islamic Education and the Limitations of Fundamentalism as
an Analytical Category 217
Florian Pohl
Conclusion 235
Gordon D. Newby
Afterword 253
Simon A. Wood and David Harrington Watt
Selected Bibliography 259
Contributors 269
Index 271
Yazar hakkında
Simon A. Wood is an associate professor of religious studies at the University of Nebraska–Lincoln and the author of Christian Criticisms, Islamic Proofs: Rashid Rida’s Modernist Defence of Islam.